Updated . Published .
Diamond Cut: What the Grades Mean and Which to Buy
Diamond cut is how well a diamond's proportions, symmetry and polish return light to your eye. GIA grades cut for round brilliant diamonds in five steps, from Excellent to Poor. Fancy shapes get no GIA cut grade. For a round, choose Excellent and compare stones inside that grade with a cut score, because two Excellent rounds can look different.
- Cut decides brightness, fire and scintillation: the white light, the colored flashes and the sparkle you see.
- GIA's cut grade covers standard round brilliants in the D to Z color range: Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair and Poor.
- Fancy shapes such as oval, cushion and emerald get polish and symmetry grades but no GIA cut grade.
- In November 2026 the StoneAlgo price calculator priced a 1 carat round G VS2 with a Very Good cut about 2.5% below the same diamond with an Excellent cut.
- StoneAlgo's cut score rates round diamonds on a 10 point scale. We suggest 7.5 or better.
🛡️ Check your diamond 💎 Search diamonds
What is diamond cut?
Cut describes how a diamond's facets work with light. For a round brilliant, GIA judges three areas (GIA):
- Face-up appearance: brightness (white light reflected back), fire (light split into the colors of the spectrum) and scintillation (the pattern of light and dark areas, and the sparkle when the diamond moves).
- Design: weight ratio (weight compared with diameter) and durability (the risk of damage from very thin girdles or points).
- Craftsmanship: polish (the condition of the facet surfaces) and symmetry (how exactly the facets are shaped and placed).
Cut is a separate thing from shape. Shape is the outline, such as round, oval or pear. Cut is how well that shape was made.

What are the GIA diamond cut grades?
GIA has graded cut on reports for standard round brilliant diamonds in the D to Z color range since 2006. Each round gets one of five grades. The grade comes from measured proportions and visual checks, and the lowest result in any area sets the final grade (GIA, Estimating a Cut Grade).
| GIA cut grade | Table % allowed | Total depth % allowed | Our advice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Excellent | 52% to 62% | 57.5% to 63.0% | The grade we suggest for a round |
| Very Good | 50% to 66% | 56.0% to 64.5% | Some look close to Excellent; check the cut score |
| Good | 47% to 69% | 53.0% to 66.5% | Expect less brightness and sparkle |
| Fair | 44% to 72% | 51.9% to 70.9% | Avoid for a center stone |
| Poor | Outside the Fair range | Outside the Fair range | Avoid |
The ranges are the widest values each parameter can have and still reach the grade. A diamond inside them can still grade lower when its angles interact badly. Our depth and table guide explains these numbers and the crown and pavilion angles behind them.
How is cut judged for fancy shapes?
GIA's cut grade applies only to standard round brilliants; other shapes are fancy shapes. A GIA report for an oval, cushion, emerald or other fancy shape grades polish and symmetry but gives no overall cut grade. To judge a fancy shape:
- Look at photos or video for dark areas across the middle of the stone.
- Check the length to width ratio for the outline you like.
- Compare table and depth with the typical ranges in our shape guides, such as the oval cut diamond guide.
- Choose Excellent or Very Good polish and symmetry.
The AGS Ideal Report by GIA adds a light performance grade for round brilliants and some fancy shapes, including cushion, oval, emerald, radiant and princess cuts.
What is StoneAlgo's cut score?
Two rounds with the same GIA grade can look different, because each grade covers a range of proportions. StoneAlgo's cut score uses a round diamond's table, depth, crown angle, pavilion angle, girdle and other measurements to predict how well it returns light, on a 10 point scale. A 7 is about average for a GIA Excellent round. We suggest 7.5 or better.
You can see the cut score of any GIA or IGI graded round in the diamond check, and filter by cut score in diamond search. Our round cut diamond guide covers the other things to check in a round.
How much does cut change the price?
In November 2026 the StoneAlgo price calculator priced a 1 carat round G VS2 with a Very Good cut at $3,641, about 2.5% below the $3,735 estimate for the same diamond with an Excellent cut. In the same calculator, moving from G to F color added about 8%, and moving from VS2 to VS1 clarity added about 15%.
Because the step up to Excellent costs little, we suggest Excellent for a round. Check prices for your own spec in the diamond price calculator, or compare real listings in the diamond comparison tool.
How does cut work with color, clarity and carat?
Cut is one of the 4Cs, with color, clarity and carat weight. A well cut diamond returns more white light, which can make a faint tint or a small inclusion harder to notice. Our guides cover the other three: diamond color, diamond clarity and diamond carat size. Proportions also change how large a diamond looks for its weight; see our guide to visual carat.
🛡️ Check your diamond 💎 Search diamonds
Frequently asked questions
What is the best diamond cut grade?
Excellent is GIA's top cut grade for round brilliants. Inside Excellent, a higher cut score points to better light return.
Is a Very Good cut good enough?
It can be. Some Very Good rounds look close to Excellent, and in November 2026 the price gap at 1 carat was about 2.5% in our calculator. Check the cut score and a video before you buy.
Does GIA grade cut for oval or princess diamonds?
No. GIA gives an overall cut grade only to standard round brilliants. Fancy shapes get polish and symmetry grades.
What is a triple excellent diamond?
A round diamond with Excellent cut, Excellent polish and Excellent symmetry on its GIA report. Jewelers use the term; GIA reports list the three grades separately.
What is the difference between diamond cut and shape?
Shape is the outline, such as round, oval or pear. Cut is how well the diamond's facets are proportioned and finished to return light.